Abbey (3 seats)
| Candidate | Party | Votes |
| *Mrs K. Alford | Independent | 684 |
| Ronald Stansfield | Conservative | 637 |
| *Mrs P. Huckvale | Independent | 612 |
| R. C. Mitchell | Labour | 374 |
| T. A. Ingram | Labour | 368 |
| G. R. Darkin | Labour | 359 |
Borrowell (3 seats)
| Candidate | Party | Votes |
| *Jack Cox | Conservative | 938 |
| *Eric Bernard Smith | Independent | 839 |
| *William Bostock | Independent | 837 |
| Chris Webster | Labour | 724 |
| Raymond Tanner | Labour | 570 |
| Arthur O’Connor | Labour | 552 |
Park Hill (3 seats)
| Candidate | Party | Votes |
| *Joseph Watts | Independent | 660 |
| T. J. Prentice | Conservative | 621 |
| Frederick Dodd | Conservative | 516 |
| F. W. Miller | Independent | 413 |
| Mrs A. Birch | Independent | 393 |
Castle (3 seats)
| Candidate | Party | Votes |
| *Leonard Smalley | Independent | u/o |
| *W. R. Taylor | Independent | u/o |
| *Henry Watling | Independent | u/o |
*denotes retiring councillor
PUBLIC MEETINGS JUST FOR ‘RUBBER STAMPING’ – SAY LABOUR
The Independent group hold a four seat majority over their Conservatives rivals, one less than the election of 1955.
In their Election Address, the Kenilworth Labour Party, claimed that KUDC monthly public meetings were merely a procedure for ‘rubber stamping’ decisions made at committee. They stated that they deplored this attitude towards the ratepayers of the town. In their manifesto they said that the Square should be developed for the benefit of the people and not left until private enterprise decides to develop it for its own interest. Labour stood in only two wards with six candidates, all of which, failed to be elected.
There was no contest in castle ward as Smalley, Taylor and Watling were elected unopposed. They have been ‘Kings of the Castle‘ since the 1952 election and any opposition would have been futile.
Former Councillor, Mr Flavel had resigned his seat two months before the election due to business commitments, which left him little time for council matters.
Only four Conservatives stood in the poll and all were elected. New to the council is Mr Prentice, who has recently moved to Kenilworth, was a former Conservative member for ten years on Coventry City Council. He is an accountant and company director.

New councillor for Park Hill is Frederick Dodd, who is the licencee of the Albion Tavern pub. (Now lost)
KUDC Councillors
8 Independents (Mrs Huckvale, Mrs Alford, L. Smalley, W. Taylor, H. Watling, J. Watts, E. Smith, W. Bostock)
4 Conservatives (T. Prentice, F. Dodd, J. Cox, R. Stansfield)

Chairman

1958-59 Leonard Smalley
1959-60 Eric Bernard Smith
1960-61 Eric Bernard Smith
Chairmans Chain of Office – Courtesy of Warwickshire County Records Office. (ref. PN (N) 600/147/3)